Big Talk: Poems for Four Voices, by Paul Fleischman & illustrated by Beppe Giacobbe

Neato! This is a book of three unique poems for four voices. I've seen poetry books for two voices, but not FOUR!! Wouldn't it be great to see four students sitting down together practicing this poem... perhaps after reading they could write their own poem for four voices. What would each voice say? And, How does it interact with the other voices? What a fun project this could be for students who enjoy this kind of poetry! Or maybe you could project the poem onto the projector screen, and dividing the class into sections, read the poem as a whole. Or maybe you would have the kids decide how to divide the speaking roles. SO MANY classroom applications...

Fleischman's book is really confusing for one individual. The poetry only works properly when there are four people working together. I had to get some help reading this book. I took it with me to my mom and dad's house over the weekend. My mom, dad, sister, and I read the book together. It was hilarious. The poems are really chaotic and this is accentuated when there are four individuals trying to coordinate their rhythms and tempos. Good Times!

I guess it takes practice to read something like this. There are hints for reading it in the beginning of the book, however I still struggled at first. When we finally got it right, it sounded so cool. The words were all of a sudden filled with power and emotions.

My favorite of the three poems in this book was called, "Seventh Grade Soap Opera." It was like taking a step into the past. The poem captures the drama of the seventh grade that was so familiar. I'm not sure though, I really liked the one called, "One Quiet Evening Here" too. It was funny because, the evening was not really all that quiet with my entire family trying to get the hang of the four-voices thing. In this poem Fleischman uses really interesting choices in words to describe the "QUIET" evening. The final poem is about ghosts, we read it in "scary" voices, but laughed the whole time.

Into the Woods, by Anthony Browne

Oh! Another treasure. This book is so cool, everyone needs to read it. Actually I'm sending an alert to all teachers who may happen to read this: READ THIS BOOK ALOUD TO YOUR CLASS! SEE WHAT THEY NOTICE! What do you notice? I noticed that the book had an almost, not almost, just plain depressing undertone... until the end. Don't worry, it's a very unexpectedly happy ending.

The cover may remind you of a well-known fairy tale, actually many of the themes throughout the book are taken from various fairy tales. The boy's imagination seems to be filled with them. The story begins with a thunderstorm, a very depressed mother, a missing dad, and a worried boy. All very dramatic! Then the boy is somehow carrying a basket through the woods to Grandma's house (she's sick, sound familiar?).

You know how, when you are a child, even the smallest task can seem like a dangerous adventure? I remember being scared to death of taking anything down to "the cellar" when I was a kid. It's not that it was scary. It wasn't even really a cellar - it was a completely finished and furnished downstairs level. That didn't matter, what mattered was that my imagination was running wild - I visualized giant, drooling, warty, frog-like demons lurking in the darkness at the bottom of the stairs. It terrified me! I always had to run back up the stairs as fast as possible and push the "monster button" (the knob on the handrail) so I would be safe and the monsters would remain down in the darkness where they belonged.

Anyway, this book explores a child's fear of venturing outside of their comfort zone, and how the imagination can take over the entire experience.

Once again, the illustrations are so awesome! I love the way Browne exemplifies his gift of creating irony and symbolism not only in the text, but ESPECIALLY in the illustrations. There are hidden messages, hidden pictures, and just strange stuff going on in the forest. If you don't see it at first, look harder... and it only gets stranger and stranger as the story progresses.

Twilight Comes Twice, by Ralph Fletcher & illustrated by Kate Kiesler

I am not certain what the target age group for this picture book, but I feel that it could be appreciated by ALL ages - I definitely appreciate it! What an intimate vision this book creates! Twilight Comes Twice. I'm never up early enough in the morning to experience the morning twilight, but this book makes me feel that I know exactly what it's like. The five senses are utilized to their fullest in this poem, even "Sounds ring out more clearly" in the morning twilight. Fletcher's use of the senses creates strong images and puts the reader at the forefront of the twilight experience.

Something that I found interesting as I read the poem is this: Fletcher skipped the entire day. The activities of the day were of no importance in creating a strong representation of Dusk and Dawn. Often we get so caught up in all of our actions, that we don't remember to stop and consider the very obvious occurrences of everyday life (especially in nature - it seems monotonous or unimportant somehow, and perhaps is overlooked) and the beauty, emotions, an feelings that these everyday occurrences can create. For instance, I can tell you all about the episode I watched on TV last night, but for me to attempt to explain the sunset or sunrise - this is an entirely different thing. I would need to really "think" about it - and that is why SOME poetry is SOOOO valuable (perhaps even more so than other forms of writing, not to be biased or anything) - because the writers of poetry must "think" - and thought is what produces the strongest writing.

To explain these more abstract ideas, one must use their personal experience and all of their senses. This is the case in Fletcher's book. He really captures mood of twilight. The illustrations add a literal interpretation to the poem. They attach a person and a place and a mood and a setting to the words in a way that deepens the poem and add a real-life context! The illustrations are impressionistic, using muted, earthy colors that blur into one another on the pages.

Bella and Bean, by Rebecca Kai Dotlich & illustrated by Aileen Leijten

What a different way to approach poetry in children's literature! This may not be considered a traditional "poetry picture book," nevertheless Dotlich writes a beautiful poetic story that has short poems embedded within. The story is about two friends who have very different agendas. Bean does not understand what is so great about poetry... Bella shows her. Bella is constantly contemplating, visualizing, and writing poetry - she demonstrates to the reader how single words can represent a much bigger idea.

The illustrations are what initially drew me to the book. They are so beautiful! They are filled with lovely pastels and muted shades that create a dream-like fantastical visual of the story, the poems, and the characters. Oh, did I mention that Bella and Bean are mice? They are. They wear little shoes, hats, bows, sweaters, and scarves - such sweet representations of the two unique characters.

Throughout the story, which is itself written in poetic language, there are short poems that are developed by the characters. Bean is reluctant to accept Bella's devotion to poetry, but by the end she identifies with the linguistic and emotional power that can be represented by written words. I can imagine reading this book to young children who are just being introduced to the ideas of poetry - after reading you could pair students and they could write a poem together, much like was done in the book by the characters Bella and Bean. This would be a great resource for students who may be reluctant to try using poetry.

This reminds us, as teachers, that children love to play around with words. I remember when I was a kid I thought the word "pants" was hilarious, for whatever reason I don't really know why... It just sounds funny - "Paaaannnts" (you have to really accentuate the "aaaa" sound!) Anyway, we can use the alphabetic and phonetic infatuations of children to get them thinking about poetry as a means for communicating.

Oh, Brother! by Nikki Grimes & illustrated by Mike Benny

This is an interesting book. It begins with a poem about a wedding. Two families join, and through poetry, this book tells the feelings of a young boy when he acquires a "new brother." He shares feelings of jealousy and anger in the beginning of the book. The boy feels that his new brother is taking his place. Eventually, he warms up to his new family. The poetry really captures the emotions and feelings of the boy. This is a really relatable, sweet story about mixed family. It represents the fear and feelings of abandonment that can be felt by children who have lost a parent. I was really touched by the words, it seemed as if they came from .

The poems are written with "natural rhymes" and the twenty individual poems seem to flow with one another, and build upon the previous poem. There are poems of many different lengths - some are only three lines (haiku), others have several stanzas and span two pages of the book. The author uses the senses to create strong feelings in a reader.

The large scale illustrations are well done, and one can see that the illustrator and the author worked in close collaboration in their creation of the illustrations. Each illustration represents the poem on its corresponding page/s. They create really neat visual representations of the author's words. For instance, in the poem titled "Mouse" the boy feels so small in his home with two new family members. The illustrator shows the tiny boy at the ankles of the four new feet.

This is a book of poems that could be VERY useful in a classroom setting!

Bear Hunt, by Anthony Browne

This is another great picture book by Browne. The story, as said in its title is about a bear hunt. The only actual characters are Bear and two hunters. The hunters try to get the bear using increasingly violent methods, but the bear counters the attacks by drawing his way out of trouble. Yep, that's right! Drawing. Bear takes out his pencil and draws a rhino to scare the hunter, or draws a string to trip the hunter...

I just kept thinking about one of my all time favorite books from childhood: Harold and the Purple Crayon, by Crocket Johnson. Much like Harold and the Purple Crayon, the story builds upon the idea of a magical writing tool. In this case it is a pencil. It's a good thing Bear has that pencil!

The story NEEDS the illustrations to be understood. Without the pictures, the text would have little meaning. AND... THE ILLUSTRATIONS ARE WACKY!! There's a lot of really strange detail added into the brightly colored forest scenery of the book. For instance: fingers pop out from behind a fern, green lips form the leaves of a flower, some plants wear top hats, and other plants wear shoes, a bird is shaped like a teapot, etc.

There are so many opportunities to get lost in the illustrations, which is likely ONE MAJOR reason why I seem to enjoy Browne's work so much!

Piggybook, by Anthony Browne

What a little jewel! I just discovered this author, his books are bizarre and AWESOME! This book by Browne shows how Mom must work harder than everyone. After reading the book, I feel bad for all of the years I yelled, "Mom! Can you _____."

Mom gets up earlier than the rest of the family, she makes breakfast, wakes up the kids, and keeps everyone on time. After Dad goes to work and the kids go to school, Mom must do the breakfast dishes, make the beds, and vacuum the carpets. She keeps the order. After that, she goes to her own job! POOR MOM!

I think it is EXTREMELY interesting how the author creates the mother in totally different light than the other members of the family. The author makes a clear divide in the beginning, Mom's work is much less important than the work/school of the other family members. She is basically faceless in the book, chin down as she goes about her motherly roles in which the family expects of her. Mom wears all grey, a frumpy and careworn look - the illustrations that contain her are gloomy, sad. It makes a reader really feel bad for Mom, her entire life is dedicated to service.

There are really cool effects in the illustrations, which one must look very closely to find. Small details such as stained clothing and crumpled newsprint make the illustrations unique and engaging. What's more, is that many of the illustrations have some sort of a "mistake" (perhaps for foreshadowing purposes: an example can be seen on the page where Dad shouts at Mom, "Hurry up with the meal, old girl," (because he's too lazy to get out of the big comfy chair). What's interesting about this illustration in particular is that Dad's shadow on the wall, is a fat pig!!! FUNNY! The author plays around with ideas of stereotypes in a new and humorous way.

In the end the reader is presented with an unlikely role reversal! Good stuff!

Thank You, Mr. Falker, by Patricia Polacco

Oh! I exclaim in delight! This is one of the most touching books I have ever read. People must read this book - ESPECIALLY TEACHERS - it will provide an even greater sense of purpose.

It is refreshing to see that there are children out there who grow up to be adults (like Polacco) that recognize the good teachers out there and how they helped make a REAL difference. This is why we teach, so that we may try to reach out and offer guidance, undivided caring and interest in our students, and the undying vow to educate and therefore enlighten every child. Sounds reminiscent of a utopian vision, but I swear: if every educator lived what they preach we wouldn't have stagnate dead-beat teachers out there who go through year after year after year after year teaching the same stale curriculum to bored, unenlightened students. Each new year should be a new academic adventure for students, we as teachers need to make that happen. I can only hope that someday a child can look back on their experience in my classroom and think, "Wow, now that's a teacher who really made a difference for me," or "She really helped me out during some difficult times." What a gratifying thought for a future educator.

I felt close to Trisha (Patricia Polacco) the young girl in the book who was struggling with academics, especially reading and math, and who often found refuge in her artistic abilities. Trisha thought she was "dumb" and the other kids teased her to the point of self-isolation and withdrawal. The book showed how lonely she felt, being the subject of ridicule and harboring a very dangerous secret: she had never learned to read. . . Until finally after a move to California and a new fifth grade teacher, her learning disability was recognized, dyslexia. Mr. Falker ended the ridicule in his classroom and pointed out the artistic giftedness of Trisha, which did not go unnoticed by her peers.

To think that there was only ONE teacher out there that was able (and willing) to invest enough of themselves to see through Trisha's shy exterior and withdrawn behavior in school to detect a REAL ISSUE saddens me, but gives me hope at the same time. I will be that teacher, and I can only hope that every other teacher in the world can say the same.

We should all be Mr. Falkers!

Thunder Cake, by Patricia Polacco

Mmmm. I'm hungry now. Thunder cake looks amazing.

Why are we so afraid of thunder as children? It's loud noises in general - it just disturbs the senses, confuses, disorients... Polacco writes a brief prologue explaining her motivation for this story.

Polacco uses this book as a means to explain how her Babushka (grandmother) helped her to overcome her own childhood fears of the noisy and terrifying midwestern thunder storms. It is a story that portrays a strong bond between the young girl and her grandmother. The warmth of the story is felt by the reader, and a smile slowly grows on your face as the story progresses. We learn that sometimes distraction and companionship can diminish our fears. It's even better when we get yummy cake during all of it.

Polacco uses wonderful pencil drawings with watercolors in earthy tones paired with details of traditional Russian influence to recreate the farm in Michigan where her grandparents lived. The illustrations show the storm getting closer and closer, and throughout the text the sounds of thunder get louder and longer. Kabooom, boooooom ba-babooooooooom, crackle crackle boooooom ka-boooooom... Ha! That would be fun to read aloud to a room full of kindergartners!

The pair of characters travel all around the farm to collect all of the ingredients for the cake, all the time the reader feels the strength and comfort that is provided by Babushka. And, by the time the cake is finished baking the fear of the thunder has lifted, there was nothing to be afraid of anyway!

At the end we even get Babushka's recipe for thunder cake, yummy, what a tasty treat during a thunder storm!

Pink and Say, by Patricia Polacco

What a book! Polacco knows how to take a story that has been told to her and put it into beautifully composed words and illustrations. After having read this book, I was filled with a newly acquired sense of understanding of the events that occurred in our country between the confederate and union states during the Civil War. I cried. How could there have been a time when people were bought and sold? A time when people were publicly beaten and hanged because of their skin color? It seems completely foreign, but it is literally VERY close to home. AND the fact-of-the-matter is, there is still racist behavior and prejudices of all kinds in this country.

We as teachers MUST work harder than anyone else to combat these evil forces if we want to create a future that continues to foster ideals of kindness, compassion, and sensitivity toward others.

The story of Pink and Say is a true story about two young Union soldiers from different outfits. Sheldon (Say), a 15 year old white boy was badly wounded when Pinkus (Pink) a black boy about the same age as Say finds him suffering in the tall grass and carries him to the safety of his family's home where Pink's mother cares for Say until he is healthy again. The book is dramatic, portraying feelings of sadness, loss, and inadequacy.

I wish I could say the ending is a happy one, but like most stories of war - the book ends in tragedy also. Polacco did not set out to glorify the war in this book. She instead set out to create an accurate portrayal of the hardships faced before the abolition of slavery in America. This would be a great piece of fiction to use in the classroom; I wonder if students would be as touched as I was?!?!

When Lightning Comes in a Jar, by Patricia Polacco

When Lightning Comes in a Jar was inspired by Polacco's love for storytelling and her dedication to passing on her memories of family.

The story is about a family reunion and a special event that took place. Every family reunion was so predictable for the young girl (Polacco) in the story, she thought she knew exactly what would occur because it was the same year after year. First the cousins would come, then the Jell-O molds and meatloafs would be brought to the table, then the annual baseball game, the bag races, watermelon seed spitting contest, then the storytelling . . . But this summer, Gramma told her that something else would happen, as she suggested: "And we might catch lightning in jars."

Of course, what child wouldn't be intrigued by such a comment, LIGHTNING IN JARS!!! What in the world does that mean. The entire day of the reunion adds to the suspense surrounding this activity that was soon to take place, catching lightning in jars. The family gather for the storytelling and the children are all extremely anxious to discover what this may mean. Finally, after dark, the jars come out and the "magic" begins.

The story ends with Polacco sharing how the tradition of catching lightning in jars is carried on today by her family. The final words and images of the book leave the reader longing to carry on their own family traditions, allowing the imprints of the past to become an essential part of building the future.

The Keeping Quilt, by Patricia Polacco

Yet another rich picture book by Polacco filled with themes of family tradition and strong cultural influence. The story evokes the emotions in a reader that create a strong reaction and the feelings make one contemplate the memories of their own family tree. The "Keeping Quilt" reminds me of the patchwork teddy bears that my grandma made out of my grandpa's old shirts after he died. She made one for me and all of my cousins. Perhaps someday, someone will use my old clothing to make something that can be shared with the family I will never know. Memories need to be passed on, quilts and stuffed animals can hold be way to keep the memories alive.

The text flows beautifully from page-to-page. It tells the story of a quilt made of the clothing of relatives past, which has been passed through the generations and is currently in the care of Polacco's own children. The story speaks of the possession of the quilt, how it was made by the elders of Great-Gramma Anna's generation when their family had just moved to America. Then, how it was used, as a tablecloth before the Sabbath, as a huppa at the weddings of the girls of four generations, as a cape or a tent when children played, as a picnic blanket, to wrap a new baby in . . . When each young girl became old and then died the family mourned, but the quilt was still passed onto the next generation.

The color in The Keeping Quilt is again (like Emma Kate by Polacco), focused on contrast. The pencil drawing illustrations are all black and white, except the QUILT which appears on every page in all of it's colorful glory. The characters on the pages reflect the emotions of the story, weeping over the death of a loved one, or rejoicing with the happiness of welcoming a newborn into the world. It is really neat that Polacco chose to depict her own family in the book, it gives more than a glimpse into the life of an amazing author and woman.

January's Sparrow, by Patricia Polacco

This book, written using a modified dialect from Unchained Memories: Readings form the Slave Narratives, tells the dramatic and heart-wrenching story of the Crosswhites - A family who flees a Kentucky plantation after a young man, January, is brutally beat and left for dead in the streets. January had whittled a wooden sparrow for Sadie, the main character of the story. Although they weren't really related as family, Sadie and January were as close as brother and sister. When the family leaves the plantation, Sadie forgets the priceless wooden sparrow from her "eldest brother" January for whom a grave was dug by Sadie's father before they ran. Sadie continues to think about the message the little bird stood for: "".

The reader becomes attached to the family and hopes for their safe escape. They find refuge in Marshall Michigan after traveling for some time on the Underground Railroad. Finally the little wooden sparrow resurfaces with a note of warning from the slaveholders: "I found you." The family once again fears for their lives. The entire community of Marshall, both black and white, fight for the rights of the Crosswhites, "people ain't nobody's property!"

The reader is surprised by a pleasant ending and an unlikely reunion at the end of the book. Polacco really knows how to reach out with the emotions of creativity in text and illustrations, to grab your interest and really make you think about how it may have been for this family in the 1840's.

The illustrations are large, colorful, and descriptive. Accurately depicting the emotions on the faces of the people in the story. There are some pages that may be considered violent or graphic, but I feel that this is only necessary to create such strong feelings and reactions from a reading audience.

January's Sparrow is a long picture book - 94 pages (was in the fiction section of the curriculum lab). I think that this would be a wonderful book to read aloud in a classroom to introduce ideas of racial discrimination, prejudice, and civil rights movements, or to just get kids thinking! Thinking about the history of this country, and what we can do as people of the future to continue to expand the growing ideals of acceptance and compassion.

Babushka Baba Yaga, by Patricia Polacco

OOOOoooo! What an exciting and magical book. I found myself REALLY enjoying the story of the old ones (Babushkas - grandmothers) and the Baba Yaga (creature of the forest, the last of her kind) who longed to be part of the community of elders. The characters are so unique, which has been the case with Polacco's books. The author came from a family of storytellers with rich family heritage, and has taken a Russian folktale which was told to her, and adapted it in this picture book.

The Baba Yaga in this book is an enchanted creature who is constantly surrounded by little fairies and forest animals. She has pointed ears, deeply creased skin, a scrunchy face, and is covered by earth. The Baba Yaga sneaks into one of the Babushka's gardens and "borrows" some of the clothing hanging on the clothes line. She disguises herself as a Babushka and introduces herself to the villagers and becomes "Babushka" herself. She begins caring for a little red-haired, freckly boy - Victor. The illustrations use bright, vibrant palette of watercolors to illustrate the magic of the forest and warmth and feelings of community and security in the village.

The Babushkas (and Baba Yaga) are all gathered together one afternoon telling stories and legends, when the tale of the Baba Yaga comes up. The Babushkas speak of the horrible witch-like creature who lurks in the forests and at night comes into the villages and steals children from their beds. The Babushkas say that the Baba Yaga gobbles up babies. The Babushkas threated the children:

"And if you don't behave, she'll come and get you!"

How horrifying! Victor was deeply troubled at the thought of a creature who eats children, and the Baba Yaga feared that she would be discovered and therefore destroy the bond she had created with the boy. "She left, never to return." Finally the Baba Yaga is able to prove herself as a loving being who has been greatly misunderstood, and the people of the village open their hearts to the Baba Yaga.

An important message is learned:
"Those who judge one another on what they hear or see, and not what they know of them in their hearts, are fools indeed!"

What a delightful story! Good for all ages!

Emma Kate, by Patricia Polacco

This is a short (I think it's one of Polacco's shortest), sweet book about two best friends who do everything together. One friend is a little girl, and the other is a big, grey, wrinkly elephant. The reader wonders the entire time, "Which friend is Emma Kate?" at the very end of the story, Polacco reveals who's who.

This a book that almost every child can relate to - imaginative play and friendship are close to the hearts of children. Polacco has based this story on an imaginary elephant friend from her own childhood.

Polacco has a vivid imagination herself and this imaginative quality is reflected in both the stories and illustrations of her children books. The illustrations in this book are very lovely. She uses a realistic style and close attention to detail to create intricate pencil drawings. The detail is so neat! The weight of the elephant becomes apparent when the reader sees that the sofa is crushed like an accordion when the elephant sits down, and the bike tires are flattened out from the enormous size of the elephant when the two friends ride double.

Polacco's use of color in this book is very interesting. She chose to use watercolor selectively in the illustrations to create contrast between the characters, objects, and interactions between them. The little girl's dress for instance, is painted in a vibrant red with a blue flowery pattern - the pattern of the dress is part of every illustration - it is the only constant color carried from page to page, otherwise the majority of the illustrations are done in black and white.

Uncle Remus and Brer Rabbit, by Joel Chandler Harris

I'll just come right out and say it, the controversy surrounding this classic piece of American literature is racism. But when making assumptions like this, one must keep in mind the era that these stories were written and published, the experiences of the author, and the message the book is may be trying to spread.

First, Harris wrote the Uncle Remus stories in the early twentieth century, during the apex of segregation and slavery in the South. The story is told and narrated in the accurate African-American Southern dialect of the time, and the "racial slurs" used in the story did not become "slurs" until we socialized them as such.

Second, Harris, although White, was extremely interested in African-American folklore and story-telling. He worked on a plantation and had the opportunity to socialize, listen, and learn from the African-American slaves that also worked there.

Third, the themes represented within the community of animals have been viewed as similar to that of the early American plantation. I do not feel that the message was meant to be racist when Harris created the Uncle Remus characters, but rather a refection of what was going on in the South at the time.

My dad read this book to me when I was very little and I did not realize that it had any sort of "negative" racial message at all, in fact I enjoyed hearing my dad read with the southern accent, it was engaging and different. It wasn't until I got a bit older (seventh grade maybe) and I found the book on the bookshelf, remembering my fondness of it, that I opened it up and was appalled by the racial slurs and undertones. I couldn't believe that this had been among my favorites to hear as a child. This is interesting to think about: as we develop the ability to decide "what is racist" for ourselves, we also develop the ability to decide "whether we agree with it."

The House That Crack Built, by Clark Taylor

Whew! That was an oddity of book - I feel a little unsettled, I NEVER thought I would be reading a children's book about crack. Taylor took the nursery rhyme, "The House that Jack Built," and morphed it to encompass the story of how a crack house tore down an entire community. The abstract people make them seem In the end there is hope for CHANGE.

Controversial and "unfamiliar" maybe, but the truth of the matter is, that in many schools around the country where there is an overwhelming population of children who are directly impacted by drug use/abuse, whether it be within their peer group, their families, or their community. No matter how much we may wish to pass off children as "innocents" their lives are complex and difficult too. Books like these help children understand that they are not alone.

This book is "recommended" for ages 4-8. Where this book may seem appropriate for some school audiences, I do not see how it would ever be appropriate to read in a conservative, rural elementary school, like that which I attended as a child. I imagine the uproar from parents would likely lead to a teacher's termination - however justified the reading may have seemed. With a book like this, you need to pick-and choose your audience, as introducing a classroom of kindergartners to the perils of crack-cocaine addiction may not be the best of approaches in a "home-town" school-setting.

In the Night Kitchen, by Mauice Sendak

This is another wonderful, imaginative book by Sendak. The way Sendak manipulates the story and illustrations to reflect a young child's "experiences in the night kitchen," is dream-like and surreal - I don't know if I was fully able to experience the story because of my lack of "a-child's-imagination."

I just want to say one thing about the controversy surrounding this book, "when WE relay our own negative feelings and negative connotations of 'private parts,' genders, and sexuality to children, we are only instilling them with our own interpretations, and we are depriving them of the ability to make important decisions on their own." I guess what I'm trying to say, is that, in a child's mind, there is nothing wrong with this book until we tell them there is. Anyhow, from a literal perspective, the boy needed to take his clothes off to get into the cake batter, it makes perfect sense.

Okay, one more thing . . . Everyone is so caught up in the nakedness, the religious intonation has been missed, HA! What's up with that?

Where the Wild Things Are, by Mauice Sendak

Oh, memories . . . this book was a favorite during my childhood. I remember when my dad would scare me with his bestial dramatic re-enactment of the wild rumpus!! He would hold the book open above his head, flipping slowly through each wordless page, while jumping around crazily, and grunting, making beat-box noises to the rhythm of the rumpus. Hilarious, I wonder if he remembers as well as I do?

I remember feeling sad for Max (the boy in the story) when he sent to bed for casuing "mischief of one kind . . . or another." The illustration of Max in his wolf suit holding a fork to "stab" his pet dog, and the shadow of this action reflected on the wall of the room, is still vivid in my memories of the book. I remember thinking, "Max is a bad boy!"

Even as a child I was able to recognize that Max was a "disturbed child," but was he really? Or is this how children are? Imaginative play is REAL and it is a part of their everyday lives. Reflecting the violence of the world in imaginative play, is part of developing an understanding of the world. For instance, when I got angry I remember going to my "deer stand" (below the picnic table) and gazing through the imaginary scope of my rifle to aim and kill the songbirds at my mom's bird feeder on the back porch. It really made her furious, but it was my way of using imaginative play to reflect "violent" feelings and emotions.

When these themes (such as Max pointing the fork downward to "stab" his dog) become personified in children's literature, it is not surprising that some will feel as if the book was published as a personal assault or something. Despite their opposition of good thought provoking literature, and their attempts to "ban" such "controversial" themes in children's literature, these conservatives cannot argue with the fact that children love the controversy! Books with "controversial" characters, topics, and themes are often times very relatable and intriguing for them - there's no getting away.

One last thought: the "Where the Wild Things Are" movie made think the about the book in a completely different way. I'm not sure if I was satisfied, it seems like the movie had the potential to be "exciting" and "captivating" but really it just depressed me. For all of these years I had thought of Max as a free spirit, but I came to find out (though the movie) that Max was a deeply depressed, lonely, and socially unadjusted child.

Hiroshima, No Pika, by Toshi Maruki

Imagine what it would be like to come to consciousness (or die) amidst the destruction and wreckage that is documented in the above photograph . . . This is on of many aerial photographs taken of Hiroshima after the United States government decided that, to drop an atomic bomb on the city, was the only way to end WWII.


This book has been a topic of debate among "war zealots" since the book was published in America. The debate surrounds the story that is told through the perspective of a seven-year Japanese girl living in Hiroshima on the day that the U.S. dropped the atomic bomb on the unsuspecting city of civilians. The imagery created through the text is reflected in the abstracted images of the dead and suffering women, men, and children who have been burned and charred by the "flash." Some of the images of humans are unclothed (see the cover illustration), likely because their clothing has turned to ash from the immense heat of the atomic bomb. The story is rampant with the somber emotions and feelings of loss and destruction, it is unlike any children's picture book I have ever read. This book opened my eyes to the "other side," and that perhaps, was the authors very intention.

The opposition feels that, the story is one-sided and fails to mention other important aspects of WWII, where the Japanese are the primary protagonists in the violence that occurred during the was.

I respect the opinions of others who may feel that the story is an "inaccurate" portrayal of WWII for American children, however I HAVE TO politely disagree with this closed-minded way of thinking. This is why: American children, and children around the world, are deprived of the option to decide (USING MULTIPLE VANTAGE POINTS) how to interpret historical or cultural events and the associated emotions for themselves. I feel the power of analysis and interpretation is an essential aspect of learning to think for oneself. When people say things like, "this book is too graphic and depressing for children," or "this book sends an anti-American message," they are only harboring resentment, anger, and reinforcing their own insecurities about the treachery that occurred on that day in our history. They need to get over it, there are plenty of books that tell the story from a strictly American perspective. Why is it that our culture is so egotistic that we are uncomfortable showing empathy for "others" - "others" that have been affected and impacted by OUR own acts of violence?

I'm sure many will disagree with the viewpoints I presented in this interpretation - "WHATEVER!" I FIRMLY BELIEVE, that If we limit to our children to reading stories that are always told through the American nationalist perspective - as many of them are, especially in the public school system - then we are limiting their ability to develop into open-minded,INDIVIDUAL who are able to develop unique interpretations of what they read based on all viewpoints and perspectives.